Gene Ther Mol Biol Vol 10, 123-132,
2006
Epstein-Barr
Virus downregulates expression of DNA-Double strand break repair proteins in
nasopharyngeal cancer
Prabha Balaram1,*, Smriti M Krishna1,
Susan James2, Vino. T. Cheriyan1, Sreelekha Therakathinal
Thankappan1, Aleyamma Mathew3
1Division of Cancer Research, Regional
Cancer Centre, Medical College. P.O, Trivandrum 695 011, Kerala, India.
2Department
of ENT, Medical College, Trivandrum 695-011, Kerala, India
3Department
of Statistics, Regional Cancer Centre, Trivandrum, Kerala, India __________________________________________________________________________________
*Correspondence: Dr. Prabha Balaram, Professor and Head, Division of Cancer Research,
Regional Cancer Centre, Trivandrum 695 011, Kerala, India; Phone:
91-0471-2522203; Fax: 91-0471-2447454; E-mail: prabhabalaram@yahoo.co.in
Key words:
DNA-PKcs, ATM, Nasopharyngeal carcinoma, EBV, HPV, Radiotherapy,
DNA-double-strand break (DSB) repair proteins.
Abbreviations: 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl
phosphate/nitroblue tetrazolium, (BCIP/NBT); bovine serum albumin, (BSA);
Epstein Barr Virus, (EBV); Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen-1, (EBNA-1); head and
neck squamous cell carcinoma, (HNSCC); ionizing radiation, (IR); Nasopharyngeal
carcinoma, (NPC); Radiotherapy, (RT); severe combined immunodeficiency, (SCID);
sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels, (SDS-PAGE)
Summary
Nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) is a unique cancer
due to its etiology, and incidence and viral infection pattern. Radiotherapy
(RT) is the main treatment modality and these lesions vary considerably in
treatment response. In the present study, the effect of EBV and HPV infection
on response to treatment based on the expression of DNA-repair proteins, ATM
and DNA-PKcs was assessed in NPC based on the rationale that the expression of
these proteins play important roles in the response to RT in NPC. 103 NPC
biopsies and 26 benign adenoid lesions of the Nasopharynx were collected before
treatment and graded according to WHO classification. Response to
treatment(radiation) was evaluated clinically. Western blotting and immuno histochemical
analysis were used for evaluating the expression of DNA-PKcs and ATM and PCR
using specific primers was used for detection of EBV and HPV. EBV presence was
also confirmed by EBER-ISH. 63% of NPC were EBV+ve and 30% HPV+ve in the
samples studied. Expression of ATM and DNA-PKcs was significantly increased in
NPC when compared to benign samples (p<0.001). However, NPC showing EBV infection showed
downregulation of ATM and DNA-PKcs expression (p=0.009 and p=0.011), in comparison to HPV infected NPCÕs (p=0.001 and p=0.003). NPC patients with HPV positivity also showed a
significantly poor response to treatment (p=0.002)with a higher rate of recurrence and lower disease
free survival. The study indicates that EBV infection down regulates the
expression of DNA-repair proteins and renders NPC sensitive to RT while HPV
infection up regulates their expression making the tumors resistant to therapy.
The results of the study also indicate that assessment of expression of
DNA-PKcs and ATM in biopsy specimens can be used as criteria to identify radio-resistant NPCÕs and selection of
appropriate therapy regimens.
Recent research provides ample evidence that viruses
affect response of tumour cells toward anti-cancer drugs and irradiation. Viruses
interfere with specific cellular genes, and their interaction with the tumor
suppressor genes abrogate cell cycle arrest and disturb repair of radiation and
drug-induced DNA lesions (Efferth and Grassman, 2000) thus leading to enhanced
susceptibility to carcinogenesis in tissue cells persistently infected with
viruses.
DNA-PKcs and ATM are two crucial proteins in the
DNA-damage repair pathway. Cells lacking DNA-PK activity as a result of a
mutation in any of the subunits are radiosensitive and deficient in the
rejoining of radiation induced DNA-DSBs and reduced activity in mice leads to
Ôsevere combined immunodeficiency (SCID), which is coupled with extreme
hypersensitivity to ionizing radiation (IR). Complete loss increases the risk
of developing lymphomas and impaired V(D)J recombination (Smith and Jackson
1999). Up regulation, on the other hand, was recently reported to correlate
with radiation resistance and suggests its potential as a molecular target for
novel radiation sensitization therapy for oral squamous cell carcinomas
(Shintani et al, 2003).
At the cellular level, ATM
deficiency is manifested by increased sensitivity to IR or other agents that
yield DSBs, chromosomal instability, cellular and humoral immunodeficiency,
developmental defects in various organ systems and predisposition to cancer
(Khanna, 2000; Becker-catania and Gatti, 2001). A-T carriers also represent a
large proportion of patients with enhanced radiation sensitivity (Oppitz et al,
1999). AT deficient cells are impaired in IR induced G1, intra-S, and G2-M cell
cycle check points and DNA damage repair capacity. Thus it has a surveillance
role in maintaining genomic integrity.
NPC
is a unique subset of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) and is a
rare malignancy in most parts of the world (Fandi et al, 1994). Geographical variation in incidence rates, rare occurrence
of this tumor and the persistent association with Epstein Barr Virus (EBV),
suggest that environmental factors and genetic susceptibility play crucial
roles in the etiology of the disease (Vokes et al, 1997). Sporadically occurring NPC in the West usually belong to
the WHO Type I histology and is associated with alcohol and smoking habits
(Vokes et al, 1993). In many parts of Asia, including Southern China and South
East Asia, NPC occurs as an endemic disease, and histologically, majority of
cases belong to WHO Types II and III (Nonkeratinising and Undifferentiated
types) with persistent association with EBV (Hui et al, 2002). Radiotherapy
(RT) is the mainstay of treatment for NPC. However, biological aggressiveness
and the radiation sensitivity of tumors within the same stage varies
considerably and cannot be predicted by conventional histopathological
evaluation. These facts indicate that there is a strong need for additional
predictive and prognostic factors in order to improve therapy results of these
patients. This study addresses the influence of the viruses on overall
treatment response of NPC and the potential use of
crucial DNA-DSB repair proteins, namely DNA-PKcs and ATM as biological
tumor markers in predicting clinical outcome, mainly response to RT.
A. Samples
Nasopharyngeal carcinoma samples (103) were collected
from the ENT department, Medical College Hospital, and Regional Cancer Centre,
Trivandrum, Kerala, India, with the approval of local ethical committees before
start of any treatment. The histological diagnosis was confirmed by a
pathologist and grading was performed according to WHO classification. One part
of the biopsy sample was snap frozen for protein extraction and the other part
processed for routine paraffin embedding. Radiation therapy was the sole
treatment given to these patients. Clinical follow up period was from 1 to 71
months, the median being 18.5 months. We considered in particular, the amount
of tumor mass reduction at the end of primary treatment with no evidence of
residual disease as a good response to treatment. Loco-regional failures,
recurrence, distant metastasis
etc. were considered as signs of radio-resistance (poor response). Majority of
the lesions with poor response had recurrence of the disease and hence
recurrence was taken as the criteria of a poor treatment response for analysis.
The benign lesions included cases of adenoids of the nasopharynx.
B. Western blotting
Extraction of total protein was done from
biopsy samples snap frozen and stored in liquid nitrogen. Protein extracts were
prepared in 1ml of lysis buffer [50mM Tris (pH 7.5), 0.1mM EDTA, 150mM NaCl, 1%
Triton-X-100, 0.5mM PMSF, 200U/ml aprotonin, 10mg/ml leupeptin, 0.5% NP-40] for 30 minutes
on ice. Protein lysates were quantified using Bradford assay with bovine serum
albumin (BSA) as a reference standard and resolved by 12% SDS-PAGE (sodium
dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels). The proteins were transferred to
nitrocellulose membrane (Millipore Co. USA) and the membrane blocked with TBST
(20mM Tris base, 135 mM NaCl, 0.1%Tween-20, pH 7.6) plus 3% powdered non-fat
milk. After incubation with primary antibodies against DNA-PKcs (N-20), ATM
(H-248) and b-actin (Santacruz Biotech, USA), in optimal
concentrations, the membranes were incubated successively with alkaline
phosphatase conjugated secondary antibody and visualized with alkaline
phosphatase specific chromogens BCIP/NBT (5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl
phosphate/nitroblue tetrazolium).
C. Immuno histochemistry
Indirect immuno
histochemical staining for assessing the subcellular localization of DNA-PKcs
and ATM proteins was performed using monoclonal antibodies N-20 and H-248 respectively
(Santacruz Biotech). Paraffin sections (5mm) from tumor tissue were
deparaffinized and rehydrated through a series of graded ethanol. For antigen
unmasking, sections were incubated in 10mM citrate buffer; pH6 and heat
treatment given for 5 min. in a microwave oven. Inactivation of endogenous
peroxidase activity was done with H2O2 and blocking of
nonspecific binding by normal mouse serum and BSA. This was followed by
incubation with the primary antibody, linking antibody and development of the
reaction with H2O2 as substrate and DAB
(diaminobenzidine) as chromogen. As negative controls, sections treated
similarly with PBS substitution instead of the primary antibodies were
included. The sections were evaluated using a visible microscope and the number
of positive nuclei was expressed as percentage and graded as follows; 0=score1,
1-25%=score 2, 26-50%=score 3, 51-75%=score 4 and >75%=score 5.
D. DNA extraction
Paraffin embedded tissues
were used for DNA extraction. The first and last sections (5 mm) of paraffin embedded tissues were stained with haematoxylin and eosin
and histologically examined for confirmation of diagnosis and estimation of
percentage of normal and neoplastic cells and inflammatory infiltrate. 10 mm sections from paraffin blocks were collected and dewaxed by xylene
immersion, followed by graded alcohol and sterile distilled water washes. DNA
was extracted using the standard phenol-chloroform method. 100 ng of template
DNA was used for each set of PCR amplification.
All samples
were amplified with b-globin
primers to assess DNA integrity and only samples that tested positive for b-globin were further analyzed. Primer pairs were constructed that
amplified the non-polymorphic Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen-1 (EBNA-1) gene and
the presence of EBV was evident by a 262 bp product. EBV positivity was further
confirmed by EBER ISH assay (Novocastra,UK) carried out as per the kit
instructions. Presence of HPV DNA was identified with highly conserved Late-1
gene of HPV, which encoded a viral capsid protein (HPV L1) using consensus
primers MY09 and MY11. The cases scored as HPV positive using consensus primers
were subjected to two multiplex PCR reactions (TS1-PCR and TS2-PCR) for the
determination of types of HPV infection. After electrophoresis in 3 % agarose
gels along with marker, the HPV types were scored according to the length of
the amplified fragment (450 bp for consensus HPV, 280bp for HPV 6, 152 bp for
HPV16, 216 bp for HPV 18 and 360 bp for HPV 11). Negative controls consisted of
a mixture of all the reagents used in the PCR mixture preparation, adding 1ml of sterile distilled water instead of the DNA and also a known EBV
and HPV negative sample. The positive control was a previously known EBV
positive Hodgkins lymphoma sample and HPV positive Condyloma tissue. These
samples were processed in parallel to patient samples to exclude the detection
of contamination.
The
statistical analysis of the protein status in relation to clinical and pathological
data was performed by Chi-square test for trend analysis. Students t test was used to analyze the difference in mean staining scores of
the proteins among the different variables. All p values were two-sided and considered significant at p<0.05. Kaplan
Meier survival analysis was carried out to evaluate the influence of various
DNA-DSB repair proteins and viruses on survival.
Briefly, the study
samples included patients with a mean age of 40.4 (range 9-79). Majority of the
patients were males (68%) and stage III and IV patients (64%), followed by
early disease stages, I and II (36%). 67% Patients showed presence of cervical
lymph node involvement. Local or regional recurrence of the disease was
observed in 35.6% of the NPC cases (Table 1). Follow up was available in 91
patients (6-71 months) and of these, 66% patients were alive and 34% died of
the disease during the study period.
1. Histology
Formalin fixed, paraffin
embedded biopsy tissues were used for histopathological exmination. Based on
the WHO classification, the distribution of cases were as follows; KSCC (WHO
Type I)-8, differentiated NKSCC (WHO Type II)-56, and UDC (WHO Type III)-39 (Table
1). KSCCÕs were moderately to well
differentiated squamous cell carcinoma.
Table 1. Expression
of DNA damage proteins in relation to malignancy and Stage, histology and viral
status of the lesions
|
|
No.
of cases |
DNA-PKcs |
ATM |
|
Benign
Cancer |
26 103 |
6.34
± 1.6 15.20
± 2.9 * |
1.00
± 0.01 9.32
± 2.1** |
|
Histological
Classification WHO
I WHO
II WHO
III |
8 56 39 |
14.12
± 9.32 15.32
± 4.10 15.25
± 4.66 |
6.25
± 6.25 10.26
± 3.24** 8.58
± 3.06 * |
|
Stage
Classification Stage
I Stage
II Stage
III Stage
IV |
5 33 25 40 |
55.75
± 16.52** 9.33
± 4.10 14.72
± 6.18 21.38
± 5.90* |
30.00
±19.14* 5.75
± 2.9 8.05
± 3.94* 12.63
± 4.40* |
|
Recurrence Nil Present |
46 57 |
5.74±4.08 31.30±5.61 |
1.85±0.85 20.47±4.51 |
|
Node status Negative Positive |
30 73 |
19.00±6.54 15.00±3.44 |
11.40±4.36 9.31±2.68 |
|
EBV Negative Positive |
38 65 |
24.84
± 5.80 9.56
± 2.90 |
16.57
± 4.5 5.07
± 1.90 |
|
PV Negative Positive |
72 31 |
8.12
± 2.50 31.64
± 6.8 |
3.23
± 1.40 23.45
± 5.5 |
*p value <0.05 – comparison with benign
lesions
** p value <0.001 – comparison with benign
lesions
p value <0.05 - comparison between positive and
negative lesions
p value <0.001 – comparison
between positive and negative groups
2. Detection of viruses
i. EBV detection
Among the 103 NPC tissues and 26 benign nasopharyngeal
tissues analyzed, 65 NPC samples (63%) and 7 (27%) benign samples showed EBV
positivity (Table 2) in both PCR
and EBER ISH assays. The EBV positivity of the benign lesions was restricted to
the lymphoid cells except in one case which showed mild positivity of
epithelial cells along with lymphoid cells in EBER-ISH. 2 cases (25%), 30 cases
(53%) and 33 cases (85%) were positive for EBV in WHO Type I, WHO Type II and
WHO Type III respectively (Table 2).
EBV positivity was found to be highest in the WHO III tumours and Chi-square
analysis showed this association to be highly significant (p<0.001). No
significant difference was noticed in EBV positivity in the different stages of
the disease. EBV positivity was associated with a statistically higher rate of
recurrence (45% cases in EBV negative vs 60% in EBV positive cases p=0.045) and
did not show any statistical significance with nodal status. In the EBV
positive group, the recurrence was independent of the WHO type with similar
distribution in WHOII and WHO III. The number of EBV+ patients in WHOI group
was very low.
ii. HPV detection
With the consensus primers, 31 of 103 (30%) NPC
samples and 4% (1/26) of the benign lesions were positive for HPV (Table 2). Upon further typing by TS1-PCR for HPV 6 and HPV 16
and TS2-PCR for HPV 11 and HPV 18, it was found that the separate infection
rate of the nasopharyngeal lesions with HPV 6, HPV 16, HPV 11 and HPV 18 was
2%(2/103), 19.4%(20/103), nil, and 9% (9/103) respectively. Highest frequency
of HPV infection was seen in WHOI (62.5%, 5/8) followed by 34% (19/56) in WHO
II and 18% (7/39) in WHO III (Table 2)
( Chi-square significance p=0.031). HPV 16 was the most common type with 62.5%
in WHO I, 16% (9/56) in WHO II and 15.4% (6/39) in WHO III. HPV 18 infection
was found in 14.3% (8/56) in WHO II and 2.6% (1/39) in WHO III and absent in
WHO I. 3.5% (2/56) of WHO II cases were found to be positive for HPV 6. None of
the nasopharyngeal lesions showed presence of HPV 11 and no double or multiple
infections was observed in any of the lesions. HPV positivity was associated
with a higher rate of recurrence (78.3% in HPV+ vs 57.1% in HPV-ve. p=0.04)
while no relation was seen to nodal involvement or stage of the disease.
iii. EBV and HPV
co-infection
A total of 11 NPC cases
(13%) showed co-infection of EBV and HPV. Highest number of co-infected samples
was seen in WHO Type II with 19.5% (8/56) followed by that in WHO III (8%,
3/39) and no co-positive sample in WHO I Type lesions (Table 2). Percentage of samples showing co-infection was
higher in node positive cases (82%), advanced stage of disease (73%), and among
group showing recurrence (71.4%), which indicates an aggressive clinical
course. Majority of cases showed single infection by either EBV or HPV and the
mutually exclusive pattern of EBV and HPV infection in NPC is further evident
from the significant negative bivariate correlation (r=-0.376, p=0.009) between
the positivity for the two viruses.
C. Expression of DNA-damage repair proteins
1. Immunohistochemistry
i. Expression of DNA-PKcs
a. Benign vs NPC
Staining pattern to anti-DNA-PKcs
antibody was mostly nuclear with occassional lesions showing cytoplasmic
staining. Benign nasopharyngeal epithelium expressed predominantly moderate to
intense nuclear expression of DNA-PKcs with few samples showing cytoplasmic
staining (Plate 1A-F). The
malignant lesions also showed moderate to intense nuclear positivity with
diffuse staining throughout the nucleus. Lesions showing higher expression than
the mean value in benign lesions +1 SD (14% in this case, the arbitrary cut off
for normal expression) were taken as cases of over expression. Based on this
cut off, Chi-square analysis did not yield any significant
difference in the number of lesions over expressing the protein in cancer
lesions taken as a whole (23% in benign lesions vs 24% in Cancer). The
percentage of positive cells were, however, higher in the cancer lesions than
that in the benign lesions (range: 20-100%, p=0.01). Detectable levels of
DNA-PKcs were also detected in 28% cancer cases by western blot (Figure 1).
b. Effect of viral
involvement
Opposite effects on
expression of this protein were noticed in the lesions infected by HPV and EBV.
The percentage over expression was seen in 45.2% cases in HPV positive lesions
in contrast to 16.9% cases in the EBV positive lesions. The percentage of
positive cells was higher (p<0.001) in the HPV+ve lesions when compared to
HPV–ve lesions while a lower percentage cellular positivity was observed
in the EBV+ve lesions when compared to EBV-ve lesions (p=0.047) (Table 1).
Table
2. Summary of Virus infection in NPC
patients
|
Groups |
EBV
+ (%) |
HPV
+ (%) |
HPV+/EBV+
(%) |
Co-infection
(%) |
NPC (103)
|
65
(63) |
31
(30) |
85
(82.5) |
11
(13) |
|
WHO
Type I (8) |
2
(25) |
5
(62.5) |
7
(87.5) |
0 |
|
WHO
Type II (56) |
30
(53.5) |
19
(34) |
41
(73.2) |
8
(14.3) |
|
WHOType
III (39) |
33
(85) |
7
(18) |
37
(95) |
3
(8) |
|
Controls (26) |
7
(27) |
1
(4) |
8
(31) |
0 |

Plate 1. Immunohistochemical staining of
NPC lesions showing staining with anti- DNA-PKcs antibody (Santa Cruz) X 400.
A. Benign Nasopharyngeal
epithelium showing low nuclear positivity
B. WHO type I lesion showing
nuclear positivity (400X)
C. WHO type II lesion showing
nuclear positivity (400X)
D. WHO type III lesions showing
decreased nuclear positivity (400X)
E. EBV+ WHO type II lesion with
low percentage of nuclear positivity (400X)
F. HPV+ WHO type II lesion showng
high nuclear positivity (400X

Figure 1. Western Blots of study samples
showing expressions of (a) DNA-PKcs, (b) ATM and (c) b-Actin proteins. Samples 1, 2,
3& 7 – HPV+ NPC lesions, 4 & 8 – EBV+ NPC lesions, 5 &
6 – Adenoid (benign) lesions
.
c. Correlation with
clinico-pathological variables
The expression of DNA-PKcs
were lower in the advanced stages of the disease when compared to stage I
disease but no difference in expression was noticed between the different histological
grades (Table 1). This observation
is to be confirmed further as the number of samples in WHO I type is very
small. However, this goes with the finding that DNA-PKcs is over expressed in
HPV +ve lesions and 4 of the five lesions in WHO I are HPV +ve.
d. Correlation with
recurrence and response to treatment
Expression of DNA-PKcs was
lower in lesions (p=0.006) showing no recurrence and good overall response (no
residual disease, metastasis or recurrence) to radiation treatment in
comparison to that in the lesions showing recurrence and poor treatment
response (Table 3). High
expression of DNA-PKcs, on the other hand, was positively associated with
recurrence (r=0.402, p=0.001) and poor treatment response (Table 3). Most HPV+ve lesions showed high expression while
majority of the EBV+ve lesions showed low expression of this protein
correlating very well with recurrence pattern (80% of HPV+ve tumours in
contrast to 40% of EBV+ve tumours showing recurrence) Kaplan Meyer survival
analysis showed that the expression of DNA-PKcs was closely associated with
disease free survival with majority of the EBV positive lesions showing a lower
expression (Table 4, Figure 2)
having a better overall survival. These observations point towards the
potential use of DNA-PKcs expression levels along with the viral status as a
marker for radiation response and disease free survival in NPCs.
ii. Expression of ATM
a. Benign vs NPC
The benign lesions showed
very low levels of ATM expression in contrast to higher levels in the malignant
lesions (p<0.001, Table 1 Plate
2 A-F). Most of the benign lesions
expressed cytoplasmic positivity. In NPC lesions, the expression of ATM protein
was mainly nuclear with some cases showing both intense nuclear and mild to
moderate cytoplasmic positivity. Increased expression of this protein was
observed in all the less differentiated histological grade lesions and
different stages of the disease (Table 1). No significant difference was observed in ATM protein expression in
node positive and negative lesions suggesting that the expression of this
protein is not directly related to invasion process.
b. Effect of viral
involvement
Lesions showing higher
expression than the arbitrarily fixed cut off of mean value in benign lesions
+1 SD (1.84% in this case) were taken as cases of over expression. Accordingly,
Chi-square analysis show EBV infection to be associated with a lower expression
of this protein (84.5% of the lesions showing <1.84% positive cells being
EBV+ve. p<0.001).

Figure 2. Survival graph showing the difference in survival
in DNA-PKcs over expressing and
those with low or normal expression group among NPC patients.
Table 3. Expression
of proteins in relation to treatment response
|
Variables |
Treatment Response |
|
|
-Poor (Mean ± S.E). |
-Good (Mean ± S.E). |
|
|
ATM(total) Virus – ve EBV alone + ve HPV
alone +ve |
16.60 ± 5.60 2.00 ± 2.00 1.50 ± 1.50 43.75
± 12.38*¤ |
1.42 ± 1.40* 0.00# 0.00# 25.00 ± 25.00*¤ |
|
DNA-Pkcs (total) Virus – ve EBV alone + ve HPV
alone +ve |
23.96 ± 6.70 6.00 ± 6.00 12.60 ± 7.03 46.25 ± 14.99*¤ |
2.85 ± 2.03** 12.50 ± 8.39 0.00# 0.00# |
|
|
Recurrence +ve (Mean ±
S.E). |
Recurrence –ve (Mean ±
S.E). |
|
DNA-PKcs(total) EBV-ve EBV+ve |
36.47 ± 9.07 27.04 ± 7.06 |
25.83
± 16.9 0.0# |
|
HPV-ve HPV+ve |
17.87 ± 6.38 49.22 ± 8.43** |
3.00
± 3.00 19.00
± 19.00 |
|
ATM(total) EBV-ve EBV+ve |
27.89 ± 7.59 14.34 ± 5.16 |
8.33 ± 8.00 0.0# |
|
HPV-ve HPV+ve |
0.0 34.83 ± 7.8** |
9.70 ± 4.24 10.00 ± 10.00 |
Table 4. Details of survival
analysis of DNA-PKcs showing relation to disease-free survival and viral
status.
|
Variables |
Protein Status |
Mean survival time ± S.E. |
95% CI |
%Censored |
p value (Log-rank test) |
|
Total DNA-PKcs |
- |
48.57 ± 3.71 |
41.30, 55.84 |
76.74 |
0.0180 |
|
+ |
26.60 ± 4.66 |
17.46, 35.73 |
52.94 |
||
|
Stage 1 DNAPKcs |
- |
45.84± 4.04 |
37.92, 53.77 |
75.00 |
|
|
+ |
19.00± 1.04 |
17.04, 20.96 |
78.00 |
|
|
|
Stage II DNAPKcs |
- |
41.25± 6.71 |
28.10, 54.40 |
80.00 |
|
|
+ |
24.84± 5.64 |
22.40, 28.75 |
75.00 |
|
|
|
Stage III DNAPKcs |
- |
34.57± 2.64 |
19.40, 29.75 |
57.14 |
|
|
+ |
13.50± 1.25 |
11.05, 15.95 |
50.00 |
|
|
|
Stage IV DNAPKcs |
- |