Gene Ther Mol Biol Vol 10, 147-160,
2006
Characterization of the
cytotoxic effect of a chimeric restriction enzyme, H1º-FokI
Naved Alam and Donald B.
Sittman*
Department
of Biochemistry, University of Mississippi Medical Center, 2500 North State
Street, Jackson, MS 39216-4505, USA
__________________________________________________________________________________
*Correspondence: Donald B. Sittman, Dept. of Biochemistry, University of Mississippi
Medical Center, 2500 N. State St., Jackson, MS 39216-4505, USA; Tel:
601-984-1848, Fax: 601-984-1501, E-mail: dsittman@biochem.umsmed.edu
Key words: Chimeric
nuclease, cytotoxic, apoptosis
Abbreviations: calcein-AM, (CN-AM);
diamidino-2-phenylindole dihydrochloride, (DAPI); Drosophila Ultrabithorax,
(Ubx); ethidium homodimer, (ET-HD); Fluorescein isothiocyanate, (FITC);
fluorescence activated cell sorter, (FACS); green fluorescent protein, (GFP);
phosphate buffer saline, (PBS); Polymerase Chain Reaction, (PCR);
post-transfection, (PT); propidium iodide, (PI)
This
publication was made possible by NIH Grant Number RR016476 from the MFGN INBRE
Program of the National Center for Research Resources.
Summary
Our
primary goal was to create an efficient cytotoxic agent. To do this, we created
a gene that expresses a chimeric hybrid of the linker histone, H10
and the nuclease domain of the type IIs restriction enzyme, FokI. The linkage
of the FokI nuclease domain to a high affinity but low DNA-sequence-specificity
binding protein is unique. It is highly cytotoxic. We demonstrate, by
transiently transfecting 3T3 mouse fibroblasts, that 63% of the cells taking up
the chimeric gene are killed. The chimeric protein is localized to the nucleus.
An extract of the protein produced in E. coli degrades DNA, indicating that it is
nucleolytically active. The ultimate mechanism through which the chimeric
protein produces cell death is likely through the induction of
apoptosis.
The H1, or linker, histones are a well characterized,
multivariant family of small basic proteins that play a major role in chromatin
organization (Ramakrishnan, 1997 and Widom, 1998). They bind to chromatin with
a high affinity (Mamoon et al, 2002) and at a ratio of up to one or more per
nucleosome (Widom, 1998; Simpson, 1978). Recently, it was demonstrated that H1
histone to which the large green fluorescent protein (GFP), is fused at its
carboxy-terminal domain, can enter the nucleus, where it appears to bind
nucleosomes normally (Lever et al, 2000; Misteli et al, 2000). Experiments
conducted with the H1-GFP revealed that H1-GFP binding to chromatin is quite
dynamic with a residence time on the order of a minute. These observations
suggest that the H1 linker histones would be ideal candidates for construction
of fusion proteins that will enter cell
nuclei. A potentially useful protein to deliver to the nucleus would be a
nuclease to act as a cytotoxic agent. Due to the chromatin binding properties
of H1 histone, using it to direct a
nuclease to the nucleus of a living cell could well prove to have sufficient
cytotoxicity as to be of clinical usefulness.
The nuclease domain of the type IIs FokI
restriction-modification
enzyme has been used as a source of a nuclease for the construction of chimeric
restriction enzymes (Kim and Chandrasegaran, 1994; Huang et al, 1996; Kim et
al, 1996, 1997, 1998; Kim and Pabo, 1998). The type IIs FokI
restriction-modification
enzyme was originally characterized by Kita et al, in 1989. It is useful for
the construction of chimeric restriction enzymes because its recognition domain
is separate from its cleavage domain. Several chimeric restriction enzymes have
been engineered in which the DNA recognition domain of one protein has been
fused to the endonuclease domain of FokI. These reports include the
linking of Drosophila Ultrabithorax (Ubx) homeodomain to the cleavage
domain of FokI restriction endonuclease (Kim and Chandrasegaran, 1994). This
group also reported the creation of a novel site-specific endonuclease by
linking the N-terminal 147 amino
acids of yeast Gal4 to the cleavage domain of FokI endonuclease (Kim et al,
1998). The fusion protein was found to be active and under optimal conditions,
bound to a 17 bp consensus DNA site and cleaved near this site. Subsequent
reports described the engineering of a zinc-finger-FokI restriction
endonuclease
and characterization of its DNA cleavage specificities (Huang et al, 1996; Kim
et al, 1996, 1997 and Kim and Pabo, 1998). These chimeric nucleases have also
been used in several application related studies. For example, a
zinc-finger-FokI nuclease was used to cause DNA cleavage and mediate
homologous recombination between DNA sequences in Xenopus
laevis oocyte nuclei (Bibikova et al, 2001). Similarly, the
zinc-finger-FokI chimeric nuclease was also used to stimulate gene targeting in
human cells (Porteus and Baltimore, 2003) and in Drosophila (Bibikova and Beumer, 2003). Beyond the use of FokI
chimeras to stimulate homologous recombination, the cytotoxicity of these
chimeras has yet to be evaluated. The linkage of the FokI nuclease domain to H1
would generate a potent nuclease with superior nuclear localization affinity
and avid DNA binding potential. Furthermore, since the desired outcome is to
generate lethal levels of DNA cleavage, the low sequence preference of H1
(Wellman et al, 1994; Wellman et al, 1999; Mamoon et al, 2002; Renz, 1975 and
Marekov and Beltchev, 1978) with its relatively short residence time (Lever et
al, 2000; Misteli et al, 2000) makes it an ideal candidate to reputably deliver
a nuclease to the proximity of DNA. In this paper we demonstrate the efficacy
of this idea by using a transient transfection system in which an H1 linker
histone is used to deliver sufficient nuclease activity to cells, to
be lethal.
II. Materials
and methods
A. Cloning of the vector DNA
constructs
The 588 bp FokI endonuclease domain was amplified by
Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) of the plasmid, pUC 19/FokI (ATCC) using two
primers, UNcoIFokI (5'-CCATGGGTGTGACTAAGCAAC-3') and DBamHIFokI
(5'-GGATCCATTAAAGTTTATCTCGCC-3') [all primers were from Integrated DNA
Technologies, Coralville, Iowa, U.S.A.] carrying Nco I and BamH I sites
respectively. The PCR cycle was [(95°C, 5 minutes; 95°C, 1 minute; 46°C, 1
minute; 72°C, 1 minute)x5 cycles and (95°C, 1 minute; 54°C, 1minute; 72°C,
1minute)x15cycles]. The Nco I and BamH I (all cloning enzymes were from New
England Biolabs) digested PCR product and 4904 bp pBSIIKS(-)/H1° (kindly given
by Brown, D.T., University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, Mississippi
39216, U.S.A.) vector DNA were ligated to form the 4144 bp pBSIIKS(-)/H1°-FokI.
Next, the cohesive and blunt ends generated by the sequential Stu I and BamH I
digestion of the 3578 bp PBSIIKS (-)/H1° and the 4144 bp
pBSIIKS(-)/H1°-FokI INT vectors were ligated in a two-step reaction. Using this
scheme, the sequence of H1° was fused in frame (with the insertion of a GCC
triplet coding for alanine between the junctions of the two sequences) to the
cleavage domain of FokI, to form the 4184 bp pBSIIKS(-)/H1°-FokI. For the
subcloning of FokI endonuclease, the 4184 bp pBSIIKS(-)/H1°-FokI was digested
with Nco I and BamH I enzymes. This yielded the 2988 bp pBSIIKS(-) vector, 588
bp H1° and 602 bp FokI cleavage domain. The 2988 bp pBSIIKS(-) vector and 588
bp FokI insert DNA were ligated to form the 3596 bp pBSIIKS(-)/FokI. The
construction of vector DNA sequences used for transfection, immunofluorescence,
western blot and protein purification experiments was done by similar
strategies (Dissertation, Alam Naved, University of Mississippi Medical Center,
Jackson, Mississippi 39216, U.S.A). The primary constructs pertinent to this
work are shown in Figure 1.
B. Transient
transfection of the mouse cells with DNA sequences
Balb/c 3T3 mouse fibroblasts (clone A31) from American
Type Cell Culture (Manassas, Virginia, U.S.A.) were grown and maintained as
previously described (Brown et al, 1996). Approximately 5.5x105
cells
plated in a 60 mm culture dish (Corning Inc., Corning, New York, U.S.A.) were
grown to 70% confluence. 2 μg of plasmid DNA was suspended in Dulbecco's
Modified Eagle Medium (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, California, U.S.A) [without serum
and antibiotics] to a total volume of 150 μl. 15 μl of the Polyfect
transfection reagent (Qiagen Inc., Valencia, California, U.S.A.) was added to
the DNA solution and the DNA-reagent solution was mixed by pipeting up and down
5 times. The mixture was incubated at room temperature for 10 minutes. During
the incubation period, cells were washed twice with fresh media to remove dead
cells. Three ml of the media was added to cells. After the incubation period,
1ml of media was added to the DNA-reagent solution and it was mixed by pipeting
twice. The DNA solution was then added to the cells with gentle shaking of the
culture dish. The cells were incubated for expression of the recombinant gene
and the transfectants were analyzed between 24-72 hours
post-transfection (PT).
C. Staining of the mouse fibroblasts with
calcein-AM and ethidium-homodimer cell viability indicator
dyes
The cells transfected in single-well Lab-Tek II Chamber
Side System (Nalgene Nunc Int., Rochester, New York, U.S.A.) were washed twice
with PBS, 48 hours PT and the chamber well was removed to prepare the cells for
dye staining. A combination of 2 μM calcein-AM (CN-AM) and 4 μM
ethidium homodimer (ET-HD) viability-indicator dyes (Live/Dead Cell Viability
Assay Kit from Promega, Madison, Wisconsin, U.S.A.) was used to stain the cells
and they were covered with a cover-slip for observation. A fluorescence
microscope equipped with a low magnification Nikon Zeiss (Melville, New York,
U.S.A.) lens was used to visualize the cells within 5 minutes of staining them
with the dyes. The CN-AM and ET-HD fluorescence was observed using a
Fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) and a Texas Red filter
respectively.
D. Immunofluorescence staining of the mammalian
transfectants
The cells transfected in single-well Lab-Tek II Chamber
Side System (Nalgene Nunc Int., Rochester, New York, U.S.A.) were washed twice
with phosphate buffer saline (PBS), 48 hours PT and the chamber wells were
removed for further treatment. Following cell fixation in 4% formaldehyde/PBS
for 10 minutes, the cells were treated with 0.5% Triton-PBS for 5 minutes to
permeabilize the cell membranes. The cells were washed thrice with PBS and
non-specific binding sites for the antibody were reduced by incubating the
cells in 10% goat sera/PBS for 30 minutes at 37°C. The cells were then
incubated with a 1:100 dilution of anti-myc antibody (c-Myc 9E10 from Santa
Cruz Inc., Santa Cruz, California, U.S.A.) for 1hour at 37°C. Thereafter, the
cells were washed twice with PBS and they were incubated with a 1:400 dilution
of anti- mouse IgG1-FITC antibody (Santa Cruz Inc., Santa Cruz,
California, U.S.A.) from goat at 37°C. After 1 hour, the cells were washed
thrice with PBS and treated with 300 nM solution of
4'6-diamidino-2-phenylindole dihydrochloride (DAPI) dye (Molecular Probes,
Carlsbad, California, U.S.A.) for 5 minutes to stain the DNA of nuclei. A drop
of anti-fade reagent (Molecular Probes, Carlsbad, California, U.S.A.) was added
to the slide to preserve the fluorescence intensity and the cells were covered
with a cover-slip. DAPI staining of the cells was observed with a DAPI filter
using a fluorescence microscope while the fluorescence from the myc-tagged
protein was observed with a FITC filter.
E. Western blot analysis of whole cell lysates from
the mammalian transfectants
Cells were grown and transfected in 75 cm2
culture flasks and were washed thrice with
PBS, 72 hours PT and harvested using a cell scraper. They were suspended in 1ml
lysis buffer [50 mM Tris (pH 7.5), 150 mM NaCl, 1% NP-40, 1% deoxycholate, 0.1%
SDS, 2 mM EDTA, complete EDTA-free protease inhibitor cocktail tablet] for
lysate preparation. The cell lysate was sheared by passing through a 23G
syringe, centrifuged at 10,000 g for 10 minutes and the protein-rich
supernatant was collected. An aliquot of the lysate was resolved by
electrophoresis on a 10% SDS-PAGE gel. The proteins were transferred to a nylon
membrane (Biorad, Hercules, California, U.S.A.) and non-specific binding sites
for the antibody were reduced by incubating the membrane in 10% goat sera/PBS
for 1 hour at room temperature. The membrane was then incubated with a 1:100
dilution of anti-myc antibody (c-Myc 9E10 from Santa Cruz. Inc.,
Santa Cruz, California,
U.S.A.) for 1 hour at room temperature. After three washes with PBS, the
membrane was further incubated with a 1:5000 dilution of anti-mouse
IgG1-HRP
antibody (Pierce Inc., Rockford, Illinois, U.S.A.) from goat at room
temperature for 1 hour. Detection of the myc-tagged protein was performed using
the recommended protocol of Pierce Inc. and the signal was recorded on Eastman
Kodak (Rochester, New York, U.S.A.) Biomax ML X-ray film.
F. Quantitative determination of the cell viability
of transfectants by propidium iodide staining
The cells transfected in 60 mm culture dishes were
harvested 72 hours post transfection, washed twice with PBS and suspended in 1
ml of fresh PBS. The cells were stained with (100 μg/ml) propidium iodide (PI) dye [Sigma Aldrich Corp.,
St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A] and analyzed by flow cytometry within 5-10 minutes
of dye staining. 10,000 events were captured by a Coulter SC500 (Beckman
Coulter, Fullerton, California, U.S.A.) flow cytometer. Staining was
quantitated on a log scale with respect to forward light scatter of the cells.
The background intensity of PI staining was substracted from the final
calculation for the determination of cell viability for each transfectant. The
necrotic control cells were prepared by treatment with methanol for 10 minutes
at -20°C.
G. Annexin V and propidium iodide staining of the
mammalian transfectants
The cells transfected in 60 mm culture dishes were
washed thrice with PBS, 72 hours post-transfection and harvested in the same
solution with the aid of a cell scraper. They were collected by centrifugation
at 10,000 g for 30 seconds at 4°C. The cell pellet was re-suspended
at 1x106
cells/ml in 1X annexin-binding buffer (all assay reagents were from Molecular
Probes, Carlsbad, California, U.S.A). Next, 5 μl of annexinV alexa fluor
488 dye and 1μl (final concentration of 100 μg/ml) of PI dye were
added to a 100 μl aliquot of the cells. The cells were then incubated in
dark for 15 minutes. 400 μl of 1X annexin binding buffer was added to the
cells and they were mixed briefly and stored at 4°C. The cells were analyzed by
flow cytometry within 10 minutes of the protocol's final step. A population of
cells was induced to undergo apoptotic death by a combination of
serum-starvation for 72 hours and treatment with the apoptosis-inducing drug,
camptothecin (10 μM in dimethyl sulfoxide) [both reagents were from
Invitrogen Inc., Carlsbad, California, U.S.A.] for 12 hours (inclusive of the
72 hours serum-starvation period) before the harvesting of cells for
analysis.
H. In vitro assay for the cleavage of DNA by
purified proteins
Rosetta DE3 plys S cells (Novagen, San Diego,
California, U.S.A.) were co-transformed with various pET16b vector constructs
along with pACYC/lig (kindly provided by Dr. S. Chandrasegaran, Department of
Environmental Health Sciences, The John Hopkins University, Baltimore, Madison,
21205, U.S.A.). A single colony of transformed cells was used for the
preparation of protein for a 1L culture. Production of the protein from
bacteria and its purification using metal-chelate chromatography was performed
according to instructions from the fifth edition of the Qiagen (Valencia,
California, U.S.A.) manual. Plasmid pUC 18 DNA (New England Biolabs, Ipswich,
Massachusetts, U.S.A.) was incubated with equal concentrations of
E.coli produced proteins in DNA cleavage buffer [75 mM KCl,
10 mM MgCl2, 10 mM Tris-Cl; pH 8.0, 3 mM DTT, 5% glycerol,
100 mg/ml of E. coli tRNA and 50 μg/ml bovine serum albumin]. The
digestion reaction was for 4 hours at 37°C followed by analysis of the products
by electrophoresis on ethidium bromide (0.5 mg/ml) stained 0.7% agarose gel.
III. Results
A. The
introduction of H10-FokI chimeric DNA in mouse fibroblasts is
cytotoxic
We transiently transfected mouse 3T3 fibroblasts with
the sequences coding for the H10-FokI hybrid (Figure
1, materials and methods) in order to drive abundant
expression of the H10-FokI hybrid off of the strong CMV promoter.
Viability was assessed by staining of the cells with a combination of
calcein-AM and ethidium homo-dimer dyes. This dual color assay, which
discriminates between live and dead cells, was used to observe differences in
staining pattern of H1°-FokI transfected and control cells.
As shown in Figure
2, it is evident that by 72 hours,
cells that are transiently transfected with the H10-FokI hybrid
construct show significantly more cell death
than cells mock-transfected or transfected with control vectors carrying only
the H10 or the FokI cleavage domain. The only cells showing
significant cell death other than those transfected with the
H10-FokI
hybrid construct were the control cells killed with
methanol.
B. The
H1°-FokI protein re-localizes from the cytoplasm to the nucleus in the
transfected cells
To verify that the H10-FokI hybrid
localized to the nucleus as predicted and as indicated by the cytotoxic effect
of transfection with an H10-FokI hybrid expressing vector, we
subcloned the H10-FokI hybrid, the H10 and the FokI
nuclease coding regions into a pcDNA3.1(-)myc-HisA (Invitrogen Inc. Carlsbad,
California, U.S.A) vector such that they would carry a myc tag on their carboxy
termini upon expression (materials and methods). Mouse 3T3 fibroblasts were
transiently transfected and the location of the myc-tagged proteins were
visualized by immunofluorescent-staining to the myc antigen as described in
materials and methods. These results are shown in Figure 3. As expected, H10 localizes strictly to
the nucleus. The FokI nuclease domain by itself contains no DNA binding,
recognition or nuclear localization capacity and accordingly remains in the
cytoplasm. The H10-FokI hybrid is as predicted also found in the
nucleus although some is also seen in the cytoplasm in some of the
cells.
C. Western
blot analysis of cell lysate from transfected mouse cells
A western blot of extracts of these transfectants,
using antibodies to the myc tag, demonstrates that the transiently expressed
proteins are the expected full length (Figure 4) and the cell viability results are not due to the
breakdown of any of the transfectant products. The myc-tagged H1° protein
migrates with an apparent mobility of 37 kD although the protein has a
calculated molecular weight of approximately 22 kD. This altered mobility on
SDS-PAGE gels is well described (Welch and O'Rand, 1990; Kasinsky et al, 2001;
Nicholson et al, 2004) and is due to the presence of highly positively charged
lysine and arginine residues in the carboxy terminal tail. Likewise,
the myc-H1°-FokI
protein exhibits a mobility deviation from the predicted molecular weight of
roughly 44 kD. The myc-FokI protein, lacking the H1° component, migrates as
expected on the gel.


Figure. 1. Cloning of the H1°-FokI restriction
enzyme system. (A).
Schematic of vector constructs and the DNA sequences of the crucial junctions
of H1°, FokI and H1°-FokI. (B). Restriction analysis of plasmid constructs, resolved on a
ethidium bromide (0.5μg/ml) stained 0.7% agarose gel. Lane 1. DNA Marker with
sizes as indicated, Lane 2. pBSIIKS(-), Lane 3. XbaI + BamHI pBSIIKS(-), Lane
4. pBSIIKS(-)/ H1°, Lane 5. XbaI + BamHI pBSIIKS(-)/H1 °, Lane 6. pBSIIKS(-)/
FokI, Lane 7. XbaI + BamHI pBSIIKS(-)/ FokI, Lane 8. pBSIIKS(-)/ H1°-FokI, Lane
9. XbaI + BamHI pBSIIKS(-)/ H1°-FokI.

Figure. 2. Staining of mammalian transfectants
with cell viability indicator dyes for determination of viability by
fluorescence microscopy. Live cell column shows cells, as labeled in rows,
stained with the calcein-AM dye. Dead cell column shows cells stained with the
ethidium homo-dimer dye.

Figure. 3. Cellular localization of recombinant
proteins after transient transfection. Column 1 (FITC): Recombinant proteins
detected by immuno-detection with an anti-myc antibody and anti-mouse
IgG1-FITC
antibody in cells, 72 hours post transfection with recombinant clones as
labeled for each row. Column 2 (DAPI): Nuclear DAPI staining of cells, as
labeled, shown in column 1.

Figure. 4. Western blot analysis of total cell
lysates from mouse fibroblast transfectants. Cells were transfected with
individual DNA contructs and total cell lysate was prepared from the
transfected cells, 72 hours post-transfection. The protein sample was resolved
by electrophoresis on a 10% SDS-PAGE gel. The proteins were transferred to a
nylon membrane and Western blot analysis of the proteins was done. Detection of
the signal from myc-tagged proteins was done using a combination of anti-myc
antibody and an anti-mouse IgG1-HRP antibody from goat at room temperature for
1 hour. The myc-tagged proteins were detected in the lysate and their mobility
on the SDS-PAGE was examined as discussed in the text.
D.
Quantitation of H1°-FokI's effect on cell viability
To quantify the efficiency of killing by transient
transfection of cells with the H10-FokI hybrid, we
performed fluorescence activated cell sorter (FACS) analysis (materials and methods) of cells
transfected with the H10-FokI construct or with appropriate controls
and stained with the cell viability indicator propidium iodide dye
(Figure 5). Quantitation of these results is shown, both as a
time series between 24-72 hours post-transfection, (Figure
5A) and as the average of three independent transfection
experiments at 72 hours post-transfection (Figure 5B). Mock transient transfection of cells indicates that
the procedure itself results in approximately 18% cell death. Controls of
mock-transfected, vector alone, H10-expressing, or the
FokI-nuclease-domain-expressing, each show a comparably low rate of cell death.
Only cells transfected with the H10-FokI hybrid-expressing vector
show a significant level of cell death beyond that of the transfection
controls, 44%. Control cells killed with methanol show a high death rate of
approximately 96%, confirming the assay's ability to detect cell death. We
demonstrated an approximately 70% transfection efficiency in the protocol used
in these experiments (data not presented). Knowing that the procedural death
rate is 18% (independent of transfection) and that, of the 10,000 cells
measured in each FACS analysis, after 72 hours 70% are transfected, the death
rate due to transfection can be calculated. The raw data indicates that 5,580
cells are alive and 4,420 cells are dead in the H10-FokI hybrid
transfectants. The death due to expression of the H10-FokI hybrid
can only arise from the 7,000 that are transfected, so the calculated death
rate due to transfection with the H10-FokI hybrid is approximately
63%.
These observed differences in the cell
viability of H1°-FokI transfected cells and controls were not
attributable to differences in the transfection efficiency of the cells with
exogenous DNAs themselves. The transfection efficiency of cells with various
plasmid constructs was roughly equal (± 5%) (data not shown). Moreover, the differences in
cell viability of the transfectants were not due to any other accessory
factors, such as differential culture growth conditions of cells; comparison of
the FACS profiles of the H1°-FokI transfected cells with the controls in the
absence of PI dye showed similar FACS scatter pattern. Differences were only
observed upon the addition of the dye.
E. The
H1°-FokI protein is functionally active and cleaves DNA in
vitro
Because in vivo detection of DNA cleavage in 3T3 cells
may be problematic, especially if an apoptotic cell death is induced, which in
itself leads to DNA cleavage (Arends et al, 1990; Wylie et al, 1992), we
decided to see if bacterially produced H10-FokI hybrid protein had
nuclease activity. The H10-FokI hybrid and the H10 and
FokI cleavage domains were subcloned into the his-tag containing pET16b
(Novagen, San Diego, California, U.S.A.) bacterial expression vector. The
proteins were expressed and enriched over a nickel column as described in
materials and methods. These enriched extracts were then incubated with plasmid
DNA. As shown in Figure 6, only
the extract containing the H10-FokI hybrid protein shows significant
DNA degradation. Extract from non-

Figure. 5. The transfection of H1°-FokI DNA in
mouse fibroblasts is deleterious and causes a reduction in cell
viability. (A). Mouse cells were transfected with
various DNA constructs. Cells were harvested between 24- 72 hours
post-transfection, at intervals of 24 hours and stained with the cell viability
indicator propidium iodide dye. They were analyzed by flow cytometry for
determination of the cell viability. Transfection of cells with the H1°-FokI
DNA causes a decrease in cell viability in a time-dependent manner as compared
to the control cells. (B). Mouse cells were transfected with various DNA constructs. Cells were
harvested, 72 hours post-transfection and stained with the cell viability
indicator PI dye. They were analyzed by flow cytometry analysis for
determination of cell viability. Transfection of the cells with H1°-FokI DNA
causes a decrease in cell viability in 44% of the cell population as compared
to the control cells. The results represent data drawn from at least three
independent experiments.

Figure. 6. The H1º-FokI protein is functionally
active and cleaves DNA in vitro. Plasmid pUC 18 DNA was incubated with varying concentrations
of E.coli produced proteins in DNA cleavage buffer [75 mM KCl, 10 mM
MgCl2,
10 mM Tris-Cl; pH 8.0, 3 mM DTT, 5% glycerol, 100 μg/ml of E. coli tRNA and 50 μg/ml bovine serum albumin]. The
digestion reaction was performed for 4 hours at 37°C followed by analysis of
the digestion products by electrophoresis on a ethidium bromide (0.5µg/ml)
stained 0.7% agarose gel. Plasmid DNA degradation was specifically associated
with purified H1°-FokI protein. pUC18 vector DNA was degraded to low molecular
weight species by H1º-FokI proteim purified from E.coli but not by either H1º or FokI
protein.
transformed
bacteria and from bacteria transformed with pET16b vector alone,
pET16b with H10,
or pET16b with the FokI cleavage domain, showed no significant degradation.
This suggests that the H1º-FokI protein is an effective nuclease
in vitro. Because we saw little enrichment of these
bacterially produced proteins after SDS gel electrophoreses and Coomassie
staining, we confirmed their presence in the extracts by western blot analysis
(Figure 7). The his-tagged
proteins were detected and showed appropriate mobility on the
SDS-PAGE gel.
F.
Fluorescence microscopy visualization of features associated with cell death in
the transfected fibroblasts - H1°-FokI, is cytotoxic via an apoptotic
pathway
The data indicate that the H10 component of
the H10-FokI hybrid can carry the FokI nuclease domain to the
nucleus where nuclease activity of the H10-FokI hybrid leads to cell
death. We studied the cells stained with the annexin V alexa fluor 488 and PI
dyes using fluorescence microscopy which allowed us to discriminate between
early apoptotic, late apoptotic and necrotic modes of cell
death.
Typical results obtained by studying
the stained cells using fluorescence microscopy are shown in
Figure 8. As expected, the un-transfected
live cell population showed negligible annexin V or PI dye staining. This is
because in viable cells, the membrane lipids to which annexin binds,
are localized
on the interior side of the plasma membrane, leading to negligible staining.
Viable cells also stain negligibly with PI because the uncompromised nuclear
membranes restrict access of the dye to DNA. This live cell staining pattern
was also seen with other controls (vector, reagent, H1° or FokI transfected
cells). Necrotic cells were generated by treatment with methanol. They stained
positively with both the annexin V and PI dyes. The staining pattern of the
H1°-FokI transfected cells was similar to the apoptotic, camptothecin treated
control cells. The H10-FokI hybrid cells and the apoptotic control
cells show a higher percentage of annexin V staining which is indicative of
apoptosis.

Figure. 7. Western blot analysis of the
bacterially expressed his-tagged proteins. Bacterially produced proteins were
enriched for his-tagged proteins by metal-chelate chromatography. The protein
sample was resolved by electrophoresis on a 10% SDS-PAGE gel. The proteins were
transferred to a nylon membrane and Western blot analysis of the proteins was
done. Detection of the signal from the his-tagged proteins was done using a
combination of anti-his antibody and an anti-mouse IgG1-HRP antibody
from goat at room temperature for 1 hour. The his-tagged proteins were detected
in the sample and their mobility on the SDS-PAGE was examined as discussed in
the text.

Figure. 8. The mechanism of cell death in
H1°-FokI transfected cells proceeds via an apoptotic pathway. The H1°-FokI
transfected cells exhibit pronounced surface labeling with annexin V alexa
fluor 488 and PI dye staining reveals extensively condensed nuclear DNA
characteristic of apoptotic cell death. Scale bar = 10 μm.
A quantitative assessment of the percentage of cells
in early apoptosis and late apoptosis or necrosis made at 72 hours post
transient transfection was done by flow cytometry analysis of the annexin V
alexa fluor 488 and propidium iodide stained cells (Figure 9, materials and methods). The percentage of cells in
early apoptosis is high for live untransfected cells and all control
transfections. Necrotic control cells show virtually no cells in early
apoptosis. Camptothecin induced apoptotic controls show few cells in early
apoptosis, but more in what is presumably late apoptosis. H1°-FokI transfected
cells show more cells in early apoptosis than camptothecin treated cells but
fewer than seen in live and control cells.
Following the transition of apoptosis and cell death
through time (between 24-72 hours post-transfection, at 24 hours interval) by
FACS analysis (Figure 10) shows
that all populations, including the apoptotic-positive control cells, go into
early apoptosis prior to the 72 hour time point except for the necrotic
controls. During the first 48 hours post-transfection, relatively more H1°-FokI
transfected cells were undergoing early stages of apoptosis than were in late
apoptosis. However, there was a transition such that the majority of
the H1°-FokI
transfected cells experienced late stages of apoptosis 72 hours
post-transfection. H1°-FokI transfected cells appear to progress from early
(24-48 hours) to late (72 hours) apoptosis with no signs of necrotic
death.
IV. Discussion
We have demonstrated that an H10-FokI
chimeric protein expressing gene can quite effectively kill cells into which it
is transiently transfected. We created this gene, in part, to begin to
establish the clinical potential of H1 to direct toxic agents, such as
nucleases, to the nucleus in order to kill cells. Other toxic proteins have
been created for this purpose, such as the caspases, to induce death by
apoptosis (Yeh and Yen, 20005; Yakovlev and Faden, 2001; Moffatt et al, 2000).
Because all linker histones localize predominately to the nucleus and bind to
chromatin tightly (Mamoon et al, 2002) and abundantly (Widom, 1998; Simpson,
1978; Kornberg, 1974), we hypothesized that it could be used to deliver a
sufficient amount of a toxic protein, such as a nuclease to efficiently kill
cells. We know that the H1 histones

Figure. 9. Transfection of mouse cells with
H1°-FokI DNA causes cell death via a late apoptotic event. Mouse cells were
transfected with various DNA constructs. Cells were harvested 72 hours PT and
stained with the cell viability indicator annexin V alexa flour 488 and PI
dyes. They were analyzed by flow cytometry procedure for determination of cell
viability. Transfection of cells with the H1°-FokI DNA causes a decrease in
cell viability in 63% of the cell population.


Figure. 10. Time-course analysis of the
mechanism of cell death in H1°-FokI transfected cells. Mouse cells were
transfected with various DNA constructs. Cells were harvested between 24-72
hours post-transfection, at intervals of 24 hours post-transfection and stained
with the cell viability indicator annexin V alexa flour 488 and propidium
iodide dyes. They were analyzed by flow cytometry procedure for determination
of cell viability. Transfection of cells with the H1°-FokI DNA caused
a decrease
in cell viability in a time-dependent manner as compared to the
control cells.
can
carry the relatively large green fluorescent protein linked to their carboxyl
terminal tail into the nucleus and bind to chromatin appropriately (Lever et
al, 2000 and Misteli et al, 2000). We thought that it was also likely that the
carboxyl tails, which lie along the linker DNA (Zhou et al, 1998; Pruss and
Wolffe, 1993), would position the nuclease such that it could readily cut the
linker DNA. The in vivo turnover
of H1 binding (Lever et al, 2000; Misteli et al, 2000) is also such that it
would continue to come off and rebind to chromatin to further enhance the
cleavage of the nuclear DNA. It seemed likely that such a chimera could cleave
a sufficient amount of DNA such that the cellular repair systems are
overwhelmed and the cells would die even if they had become resistant to
apoptotic triggers (Sellers and Fischer, 1999; Gatti and Zunino, 2005).
Although we demonstrate that H10-FokI probably induces apoptosis, we
have no reason to believe that the chimeric protein cannot still kill cells
that have become resistant to apoptotic triggers; presumably it would
eventually kill all cells through persistent cleavage of the nuclear
DNA.
Because the experiments reported here were intended to
be strictly a proof of principle, to see if H1 could be used to carry a
nuclease into the cell and sufficiently fragment the nuclear DNA such that cell
death would ensue, we chose transient transfection as the way to deliver the
gene expressing the H1-nuclease chimera. Transient transfection is typically
inefficient and its efficiency varies greatly, depending on cell type, vector
and transfection protocol (Sambrook et al, 1989). We observed approximately 70%
transfection efficiency and therefore did not expect to get 100% killing of the
cells upon transient transfection with the H10-FokI expression
construct. Also, not all of the cells that become transfected will necessarily
express sufficient amounts of H10-FokI to result in cell death. We
nevertheless, saw a killing efficiency of 63% (Figure 5) for the cells transfected with the
H10-FokI
expressing construct. With methods of gene delivery that result in higher copy
numbers of exogenous genes, H10-FokI will likely yield a 100% kill
rate.
Although our data indicate that H10-FokI
transfected cells kill via an apoptotic mechanism, this does not mean that it
would not kill cells that are resistant to apoptotic triggers. Except for the
necrotic control cells generated by treatment with methanol, all of the cells
that died probably did so by an apoptotic mechanism. It is known that transient
transfection with plasmids in itself can kill cells and that this death in many
cell lines is apoptotic (Rodriguez and Flemington, 1999).
H1 histones themselves have recently been shown to be
potentially lethal to cells, (Tsoneva et al, 2005). In this study, the H1 was
abundantly delivered by electroporation and the mechanism of killing was
believed due to effects on the mitochondria. When delivered via a
gene expression
system, we observe no lethality due to H1 alone. This is in agreement with
previous studies that relied on overexpression of H1 histones (Brown et al,
1996, 1997; Gunjan et al, 1990; Gunjan and Brown, 1999). We cannot exclude the
possibility that the effect of H1 alone on viability is cell-type specific;
electroloaded H1 did not have the same killing effect on non-transformed cells
as it did on transformed cells (Tsoneva et al, 2005). However, we have not seen
a lethality that can be attributed to H1 alone (Brown et al, 1996, 1997; Gunjan
et al, 1990; Gunjan and Brown, 1999). However, we typically select permanent
transfectants and the selection process may eliminate or select for resistance
to H1 toxicity. We also cannot eliminate the possibility that some H1 variants
are lethal. We have been unsuccessful in the selection of some permanent
transformants of H1 variants or mutants that can be induced to overproduce
significant amounts of the particular H1 type (unpublished
data).
It has been recently demonstrated that upon induction
of apoptosis with agents that generate double-stranded breaks in DNA, such as
with X-rays or with etoposide, the histone variant H1.2 (H1c) may be the
apoptotic inducer (Konishi et al, 2003). As with the electroloaded H1s (Tsoneva
et al, 2005), it appears to elicit a response through an interaction with
mitochondria causing the release of cytochrome C. Overall, it appears that
transfection with an H1 chimeric nuclease is a much more controllable method of
killing cells; in situ cell
specificity can be obtained by incorporating the H1-FokI gene into a viral
vector that has been engineered to be cell type
selective.
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr Susan Wellman for critical reading of the
manuscript. We also thank Dr. Robert Lewis, Kevin Beason and Susan Touchstone
for Fluorescent Activated Cell Sorter analysis.
Arends MJ, Morris RG and Wylie AH
(1990) Apoptosis: The role of endonuclease. Am J
Pathol 136, 593-608.
Bibikova M, Beumer K and Trautman JK
(2003) Enhancing gene targeting with designed zinc finger
nucleases. Science 300,
764.
Bibikova M, Carroll D and Segal DJ
(2001) Stimulation of homologous recombination through
targeted cleavage by chimeric nucleases. Mol Cell Biol 21, 289-297.
Brown DT, Alexander BT and Sittman DB
(1996) Differential effect of H1 variant overexpression on
cell cycle progression and gene expression. Nucl Acids Res 24, 486-493.
Brown DT, Gunjan A, Alexander BT and Sittman
DB (1997) Differential effect of H1 variant overproduction on
gene expression is due to differences in the central globular domain. Nucl
Acids Res 25,
5003-5009.
Gatti L and Zunino F (2005) Overview of tumor cell chemoresistance
mechanisms. Methods
Mol Med 111,
127-148.
Gunjan A, Alexander BT, Sittman DB and Brown
DT (1990) Effects of H1 histone overexpression on chromatin
structure. J Biol Chem 274,
37950-37956.
Gunjan A and Brown DT (1999) Overproduction of histone H1 varaints in
vivo increases basal and induced activity of the mouse
mammary tumor virus promoter. Nucl Acids Res 27,
3355-3363.
Huang B, Li CJQ and Tsai MW (1996) Sp1ase: A new class IIs zinc finger restriction
endonuclease with specificity for Sp1 binding sites. J Prot
Chem 15, 481-489.
Kasinsky HE, Lewis JD, Dacks JB and Ausio J
(2001) Origin of H1 linker histones. Faseb
J 15, 34-42.
Kim YG, Cha J and Chandrasegaran S (1996) Hybrid
restriction enzymes: Zinc finger fusions to FokI cleavage domain. Proc Natl
Acad Sci 93,
1156-1160.
Kim YG and Chandrasegaran S (1994) Chimeric restriction endonuclease. Proc Natl Acad
Sci 91, 883-887.
Kim YG, Kim PS, Hebert A and Rich A
(1997) Construction of a Z-DNA-specific restriction
endonuclease. Proc Natl Acad Sci
94, 12875-12879.
Kim JS and Pabo CS (1998) Getting a handhold on DNA:
design of poly-zinc finger proteins with femtomolar dissociation
constants. Proc
Natl Acad Sci 95,
2812-2817.
Kim YG, Smith SJ, Durgesha M and
Chandrasegaran S (1998) Chimeric restriction enzyme: Gal4 fusion to FokI
cleavage domain. Biol Chem 379,
489-495.
Kita K, Kotani H, Sugisaki H and Takanami M
(1989) The FokI restriction-modification system. J Biol
Chem 264,
5751-5756.
Konishi AM, Shimizun S, Hirota J, Takao T, Fan Y,
Matsuoka Y, Zhang L, Yoneda Y, Fujii Y, Skoultchi AI and Tsujimoto Y
(2003) Involvement of histone H1.2 in apoptosis
induced by DNA
double-strand breaks. Cell 114,
655-656.
Lever MA, Th'ng JPH, Sun X and Hendzel M
(2000) Rapid exchange of histone H1.1 on chromatin in living
cells. Nature 408,
873-876.
Mamoon N, Song Y and Wellman SE
(2002) Histone H1(0) and its carboxyl-terminal domain bind in
the major groove of DNA. Biochem
41, 9222-9228.
Marekov LN and Beltchev B (1978) Preferential binding of phosphorylated histone H1 to
AT rich DNA. Int J Biol Macromol 3,
145-147.
Misteli T, Gunjan A, Hock R, Bustin M and
Brown DT (2000) Dynamic binding of histone H1 to chromatin in living
cells. Nature 408,
877-881.
Moffatt J, Hashimoto M, Kojima A, Kennedy DO, Murakami
A, Koshimizu K and Yuasa IM (2000)
Apoptosis induced by 1'-acetoxychavicol acetate in Ehrlich ascites tumor cells
is associated with modulation of polyamine metabolism and caspase-3 activation.
Carcinogenesis 21, 2151-2157.
Nicholson JM, Wood CM, Reynolds CD, Brown A, Lambert
SJ, Chantalat L and Baldwin JP (2004)
Histone Structures: Targets for modifications by molecular assemblies. Ann
N.Y. Acad Sci 1030,
644-655.
Porteus H and Baltimore D (2003) Chimeric nucleases stimulate gene targeting in human
cells. Science 300,
763.
Pruss D and Wolffe AP (1993) Histone-DNA contacts in a nucleosome core containing a
Xenopus 5S rRNA gene.
Biochem 32, 6810-6814.
Ramakrishnan V (1997) Histone structure and the organization of the
nucleosome. Annu Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 26, 83-112.
Renz M (1975)
Preferential and cooperative binding of histone H1 to mammalian chromosomal
DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci 72,
733-736.
Rodriguez A and Flemington EK (1999) Transfection-mediated cell-cycle signaling:
considerations for transient transfection-based cell-cycle studies. Anal
Biochem 272,
171-181.
Sambrook J, Fritsch EF and Maniatis T
(1989) Molecular cloning: a laboratory manual,
second edition. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, New
York.
Sellers WR and Fischer DE (1999) Apoptosis and cancer drug targeting. J
Clin Inves 104,
1655-1661.
Simpson R (1999) Structure of the chromatosome, a chromatin particle containing 160 bp
of DNA and all histones. Biochemistry 17, 5524-5531.
Tsoneva I, Nikolova B, Georgieva M, Guenova M, Tomov T,
Rols MP and Berger MR (2005)
Induction of apoptosis by electrotransfer of positively charged proteins as
cytochrome C and histone H1 into cells. Biochim Biophys Acta 1721, 55-64.
Welch JE and O'Rand MG (1990) Characterization of a sperm-specific nuclear
autoantigenic protein. II. Expression and localization in the testis. Biol
Reprod 43,
569-578.
Wellman SE, Sittman DB and Chaires JB
(1994) Preferential binding of H1e histone to
GC-rich DNA. Biochem
33, 384-388.
Wellman SE, Song Y and Mammon NM
(1999) Sequence preference of mouse H1° and H1t.
Biochem 38, 13112-13118.
Widom J (1998) Structure, dynamics and function of chromatin in
vitro. Annu Rev
Biophys Biomol
Struct 27, 285-327.
Wylie AH, Arends MJ, Morris RG, Walker SW and
Evan G (1992) The apoptosis endonuclease and its regulation. Sem
Immunol 4,
389-398.
Yakovlev A.G and Faden AI (2001) Capsase-dependent apoptotic pathways in CNS
injury. Mol
Neurobiol 24,
131-144.
Yeh CT and Yen GC (2005) Effect of sulforaphane on
metallothionein expression and induction of apoptosis in human hepatoma HepG2
cells. Carcinogenesis 26,
2138-2148.
Zhou YB, Gerchman SE, Ramakrishnan V,
Travers AA and Muyldermans SV (1998) Position and orientation of the globular domain of linker
histone H5 on the nucleosome. Nature 395, 402-405.